In a previous poll "Would you buy this Anniversary Explorer III if it came out?", I presented a render of the a new Explorer II I would like to see. Since it is supposed to be an anniversary watch, and I made a lot of alterations to it, I named it Exp III, which, in retrospect, isn't a good idea, so, Anniversary Explorer II it shall be named.

Now, the watch that I presented was not to many people's taste, I remember even a poster that suffered some kind of reflux (not his initial words), so, if this happens again here, don't talk about it, just swallow it discretely.

After a fruitful intervention from @starter , the watch evolved into the one presented as PF , my preference, the one presented as STARTER , his preference, and the one presented as MUI, based on suggestions from @mui.richard , and being his preference.

To settle this disagreement, I proposed an old fashion duel/poll. May the best man win.

Gentlemen, start your votes